Post-Game Reaction: A Gilded Game?
No, I'm not going to be a cloud-cover pumper, as the title of this post may imply. In my initial opportunity to actually watch the Cats play this year, I found plenty to like. But I don't believe the 69-10 final score by itself indicates a lot about this team one way or another. With those thoughts in mind, onward.
What I liked...
Special teams being special. Two blocked punts for touchdowns. Averaging 17.4 yards and 26.0 yards on punt and kickoff returns, respectively. I also liked what was missing from the special-teams stats, namely any punts by K-State.
Josh Freeman. 16-for-21, 288 yards, two touchdowns, zero interceptions. Two games, five touchdowns passes, zero interceptions for Freeman. Yes, it was North Texas and Montana State, but he's taking care of the ball.
Brandon Banks. I don't want to give this kid a nickname that makes light of his (lack of) size, but he has to be a fan favorite. Six catches, 95 yards, and a touchdown yesterday. I keep worrying that he's going to get lit up, and No. 27 for MSU tried his best a couple times, but he's so shifty it's hard to get a hit on him. Even better, he caught a few balls over the middle of the field.
The 'other' receivers. I shouldn't single out Banks over the other guys, like Aubrey Quarles, Lamark Brown and Ernie Pierce, because the other guys were pretty good, too. Quarles' touchdown catch while being interfered with was a thing of beauty. Brown looks like he's solidified the biggest question mark we had about him: his hands. Pierce is in the same boat as Brown, very much improved from last year. I'd like to get Deon Murphy more involved, but how can you complain when his one reception went for 70 yards? Well, other than to say that he should have been able to outrun the safety, but whatever. He may still be a little dinged up.
While the running game hasn't been particularly impressive to me, it's quietly getting the job done. I can live with an average of 4.1 yards per carry, although against a team like Montana State, that number should be higher. Justin Woods was impressive late in the game.
Getting some experience for the backups. No fewer than 46 backups saw playing time in this game.
Finally, but certainly not least, a solid defensive effort. Montana State's only touchdown came on a short field after an ill-advised (more on that later) onside kick attempt. Other than that, MSU was frustrated all day long, picking up only 191 total yards. The backup defenders played well, too, holding the Bobcats to only a field goal in the second half. Of course, it looked like MSU wanted nothing more than to get the hell out of Manhattan by then, but still a very good effort.
No apparent injuries. Always good to get through a game unscathed.
What I didn't like...
The onside kick in the first half. We don't need to do that against MSU. On the bright side, it showed Brooks Rossman that he needs to kick those onsiders a little harder.
While the offense wasn't bad -- in fact, it was actually exceedingly good -- I don't think we have should get too carried away by the 69 points on the board. We scored six offensive touchdowns, but two of those came on drives that started inside MSU's 10-yard line. We never really put together a long, sustained drive that ended in a touchdown, but I guess we didn't need to given MSU's mistakes. Maybe my frustration is more that I didn't get to see that than that our offense didn't do it, given that we never punted.
The bad hold on the third-quarter attempt. The only real miscue on special teams.
Looking ahead...
K-State gets a week off to rest and prepare for its trip to Louisville on Wednesday, September 17. The Cardinals are 1-1, with a 27-2 loss to Kentucky on opening weekend, and a 51-10 win over Tennessee Tech yesterday. More on the Cardinals in the ensuing week and a half.
Around the Big 12...
Again, thanks to DirecTV, I got to see parts of a lot of Big 12 games. Six, to be exact. Thoughts below.
Nebraska 35, San Jose State 12
Nebraska went into the fourth quarter clinging to a 14-9 lead. On the day, the Huskers scored exactly three offensive touchdowns, two of them in the fourth quarter after Niles Paul's kickoff return touchdown essentially determined the outcome. Nebraska was outgained by SJSU and, but for SJSU's kicking situation that would rival that of most middle schools, the Huskers would have gone to the fourth quarter on the short end of the stick.
Nebraska appears to have severe problems along the offensive line, as Matt Slauson didn't start and Lydon Murtha didn't play at all. The patchwork line gave up two sacks on the opening "drive." The running game couldn't crack the century mark. The defense missed assignments and gave up a lot of yards to SJSU. Not a pretty game for Nebraska.
For More: Corn Nation
KU 29, Louisiana Tech 0
First of all, KU has one helluva defense. La Tech managed only 267 yards on the day. Defensive efforts like that will keep KU in a lot of games this year.
And that's probably a good thing because, outside of Todd Reesing (32-for-38, 412 yards, 3 TDs, 0 INTs), the KU offense isn't very good. Offensive line troubles continue to hold KU back, as they rushed for only 126 yards on 33 carries. The "Jocques Crawford-for-2,000-yard" watch enters week two, and after two weeks Crawford is a mere 1,951 yards short of his goal for the year after picking up 17 yards on seven carries. As a team, KU averaged 3.8 yards per carry.
Next up for KU is a Friday trip to South Florida, who got by UCF in overtime last night.
For More: Rock Chalk Talk
Oklahoma 52, Cincinnati 26
A big third quarter put this one out of reach, although OU didn't look like itself in the first half. Still, the Sooners picked up nearly 600 yards on the game, and Sam Bradford, outside of two head-scratching interceptions, was his usual good self. So in sum, not bad for what looked like kind of an "off" day.
Oklahoma hits the road next week for a matchup with Washington, who was one really stupid penalty away from overtime with BYU this week. Jake Locker should be a good test for the OU defense. If they shut him down, the rest of the Big 12 should consider themselves on notice.
For More: Crimson and Cream Machine
Texas A&M 28, New Mexico 22
Didn't see much of this one. ESPN's Tim Griffin noted that Aggie QB Stephen McGee got hurt, so backup Jarrod Johnson saw some action and played pretty well. We flipped to this one just as New Mexico was going for two, but we thought they were driving for a touchdown with the score 28-22 because the chain gang sign indicated it was first down. Whatever. A&M hung on, despite being outgained by 144 yards and only managing a total of 236 yards of total offense. Gag.
Texas A&M takes a week off before welcoming the Miami Hurricanes to College Station. Miami played tough against Florida last night, but is still pretty young. Of course, A&M appears to be just plain awful right now, so even beating the young Canes at home could be a tall order.
Texas 42, UTEP 13
This game reminded me that, if I should ever get so lost as to end up way the hell out in El Paso, Texas, I hope there's a football game going on. I'd like to see a game in that stadium. UTEP somehow outgained Texas, but this game was never really in doubt. Well, maybe it was; I fell asleep at haltime and didn't watch the second half because the overindulgence in beer and food all day caught up to me.
The Arkansas Razorbacks pay a visit to beautiful Austin, Texas next Saturday to play UT. The Razorbacks struggled yesterday against Louisiana-Monroe and the week before against Western Illinois and appear to be completely overmatched against the Longhorns.
For More: Burnt Orange Nation
Baylor 51, Northwestern State 6
Freshman quarterback Robert Griffin was good yesterday, completing 15-of-19 passes for 294 yards and three touchdowns. Baylor rolled up 537 total yards en route to an easy win.
The Bears get a chance for another win next week when anemic Washington State travels to Waco.
Colorado 31, Eastern Washington 24
In a game that must have been giving Buff fans flashbacks to 2006's debacle against Montana State, CU managed to sneak by EWU. That's probably all the positive CU partisans can take from this game, as EWU took Colorado to the wire before fading in the fourth quarter. The Buffs need some help on the offensive line, as the gave up two sacks and only managed 126 rushing yards on 33 attempts.
Colorado's takes a week off before welcoming West Virginia to Boulder for a Thursday-night tilt. This game looked a lot more exciting two weeks ago than it does now after WVU's collapse against East Carolina yesterday.
For More: The Ralphie Report
Iowa State 48, Kent State 28
I'm not really sure what to make of this game. Kent State handily outyarded ISU, 410-374, and yet was out of the game by the start of the fourth quarter. Kent State probably isn't very good, losing as they did the first week (21-0 to Boston College...who lost at home to Georgia Tech yesterday).
The Cy-Hawk Trophy is on the line next weekend as Iowa State travels to Iowa City to pay a visit to the Iowa Hawkeyes. Will Iowa be a Cyclone State or a Hawkeye State for the upcoming year? Find out next Saturday!
For More: Clone Chronicles
Missouri 52, SEMO 3
Mizzou is good. SEMO is bad. I don't have a clue why Gary Pinkel bothered to play Jeremy Maclin.
Next week the Tigers take on Nevada, who gave Texas Tech a fairly tough game this weekend in the desert. Wait, I forgot, saying "the desert" doesn't narrow down which venue was used when talking about Nevada and Texas Tech. Anyway, the game was at Nevada.
For More: Rock M Nation
Texas Tech 35, Nevada 19
The Red Raiders got a win despite Graham Harrell having perhaps his worst game ever. What Harrell lacked, Michael Crabtree made up for by racking up 158 receiving yards on a mere seven catches.
Texas Tech welcomes Southern Methodist to Lubbock next weekend. The Mustangs got hammered by Rice in their first game, 56-27.
For More: Double T Nation
Oklahoma State 56, Houston 37
Good solid win for Okie State over a UH team that could be pretty good in Conference USA this year. Wish this one would have been on TV over some of the other crap to which we were subjected.
The Cowboys take on FCS Missouri State next weekend.
0 recs |
7 comments
Comments
Is it...
Better to screw up an on-side kick against Montana State or against a future opponent?
On the one hand, I don’t like picking on the weaker teams like that.
On the other, I would rather find our weaknesses when we don’t NEED the play to work.
I would overlook this as a necessary evil, “like the fru-its of the dev-eel” (Mike Myers, So I Married an Axe Murderer).
by MadCat on Sep 8, 2008 2:41 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Good point
I never really thought of it like that. Yes, these games should be used as a chance to try things when there’s little, if any, chance that it blowing up would cost us. It does give other coaching staffs something to think about, too.
On the other hand, we didn’t line up in a traditional onside kick formation. We got practice running the “surprise” onside kick, but not the “end of game we’re desperate to get the ball back and everyone knows it’s coming” onside kick."
Not that big of a deal, now that I think about it more. Actually, I should have put penalties on my list of things I didn’t like, as we had 9 for nearly 100 yards.
We'll carry the banner high!
by TB on Sep 8, 2008 2:55 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Sportsmanship?
I work with a couple guys from Montana State and they were complaining about how even CU (I think good ol’, full-of-class Betsy Hoffman was still president last time MSU visited and won there) was more classy than K-State was last weekend. Now, I live in Denver and grew up in Fort Collins, and TB, you know the lack of respect I have for CU and its fans (and I think a majority of the country probably feels the same about them), so to be called out as having a classless coaching staff worse than those people in the Republic of Boulder felt a little like a kick to the you what.
I was in the Big Apple over the weekend and needless to say, this wasn’t a highlight game there, so I couldn’t find it at any bar in town. These MSU guys claim we left our starters in until the middle of the 4th quarter just to score as many points as we could on them and they had lost any respect they had for K-State football and its coaches because of it. They also thought that had we not done that, MSU could have had a better showing (to me, 45-7 at half seems to suggest otherwise).
Do these guys have a right to be upset?
by JSchwarz on Sep 8, 2008 6:39 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
FWIW...
From the North endzone I witnessed Ron Prince actually stop the MSU coaches coming from the Press Box to tell them his opinion of them doing a ‘hell of a job as coaches’. He appeared very sincere and spent a good deal of time talking to them after the game…much more than the usual ‘Good game, guys’.
I don’t think coach Prince was trying to be an asshole during the game. As for starters being left in the game…honestly, I think we pulled the QB, RBs, and probably the receivers during the 3rd quarter. I’m sure a lot of the starting OL and defense were still in there. I don’t think Coffman threw that many passes, other than to sustain the drive.
It is certainly easier to view a team as classier than another when you consider that your team won in one instance, but got beat in another. I can’t say that I’m awfully sorry though…K-State fans have been considered a little thin-skinned in the past. As fans, we (as in everyone) just have to get over it and move on.
by MadCat on Sep 8, 2008 11:13 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Holy cats, Schwarz is alive.
First of all, we didn’t pay a team like Montana State to come to the Bill just so we could disrespect them. We bring in a team like that to iron out our kinks. We try plays like the on-side kick to see if they work in game situations. We see what our offensive is capable of. We see what our defense is capable of. MSU should have been recently reminded of how and why teams do this. Do your MSU guys remember not just one week ago? They were up 38-0 at the half against Adams State and had starters(starting WR making his 3rd receiving touchdown none-the-less)making long plays in the middle of the third quarter. How many points did they end up scoring? Sounds like a bunch of hypocrites to me.
Collect your paycheck. Play the game like it’s meant to be played. Go home happy.
Man do I hate Longhorn fans, well except for the ones that actually went there.
by mystman995 on Sep 9, 2008 8:49 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
We played, what, 65 guys?
Or something like that? Hell, there were guys that I’d never even heard of on the field, and that says something because I have a spreadsheet of our roster and scholarship players.
We pulled Freeman in the third, so the comment that we left the starters in is ludicrous. We may have left some of the ‘new’ starters in longer, but that’s because they need reps in a game situation.
I honestly thought Kansas State was pretty merciful in this game. KSU could have done ANYTHING it wanted all game long. I thought the paying fans suffered the most because this game had all of the enthusiasm and excitement of a Spring Game.
This is the reality of scheduling FCS teams. Sure, once-in-awhile, they may give you a game, but really, not to insult your MSU co-workers, KSU didn’t even play that well, and they STILL scored sixty-nine. The honest truth is that KSU is a decent team, MSU is a FCS team, and this is the kind of score that you should see in a game like this.
This is not an occult science. This is not one of those crazy systems of divination and astrology. That stuff's hooey, and you've got to have a screw loose to go in for that sort of thing. Our beliefs are fairly commonplace and simple to understand. Humankind is simply materialized color operating on the 49th vibration. You would make that conclusion walking down the street or going to the store.
by Panjandrum on Sep 9, 2008 11:51 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Those guys have no reason to be upset.
Josh Freeman played the first drive of the second half and then he was done.
We scored 24 points in the second half. Chris Carney — starting DB — scored a TD on a blocked punt with 5:36 to play. Courtney Herndon -backup DB - scored a TD on a 43-yard fumble recovery. Justin Woods -third or fourth string RB - scored a TD on an eight yard run. On our final scoring drive, MSU gave us 45 yards worth of penalties. Kind of hard not to score when that happens. We ran the ball on 28 out of 35 plays in the second half.
We did everything we could to call off the dogs. I’m sure MSU is a proud FCS program and it stings them to get beat like that. But Panjandrum is correct, this is what’s expected to happen in these games.
We'll carry the banner high!
by TB on Sep 9, 2008 12:17 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs














